Comments on: Movie Review: WATER FOR ELEPHANTS

By: Rachel

Rachel — Tue, 03 May 2011 04:58:03 +0000

Sounds like the movie was better than the book. I had to read it for book club a few years back and it’s on my list of worst books. I have also noticed that most people like the book and am always stunned. It may not have been the actors that weren’t any good at the characters; it may just have been the source material. (Of course, as source material, I’m clearly biased on this one.:)

By: Pop Culture Nerd

Pop Culture Nerd — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 21:29:33 +0000

Poncho---Waltz is amazing. Let's hope we see something different from him soon. Hira---Reese was mopey and sad through much of the movie so she didn't even get to display her sunny side. Who did you picture for Jacob? Shell---One scene would stress you out so it's a good idea for you to avoid this movie. I think you'd love Tai, though. She's so cute and cuddly for such a giant animal.

By: Coffee and a Book Chick

Coffee and a Book Chick — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 12:46:42 +0000

Hmm. Not sure if I ever gave a lot of thought as who would be the perfect choice in Hollywood to play the characters since I hate it when they do make them into movies. Most books aren’t done justice when they’re translated to film (we know that), but Robert Pattinson is not someone I think of for this character. And Reese Witherspoon? I haven’t been happy with most of her movies since Sweet Home Alabama.

By: Shell Sherree

Shell Sherree — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 09:50:12 +0000

The ads have just started for this one, so we aren’t too far behind. Not that it matters in this case, as I won’t be trotting along. I vowed years ago not to watch movies with animals in them and even then, I’m often caught out ~ they sneak in as bit parts and I’m stressed for the entire movie hoping nothing happens to them! But it’s good to know your thoughts on this one anyway, PCN ~ I always enjoy reading your astute perspective.

By: Hira Hasnain

Hira Hasnain — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 08:02:38 +0000

First of all, I definitely did not picture Robert Pattinson for Jankowski. Reese for Marlena seemed like an okay choice, since she has that sunny disposition but can turn a dark corner, when needed. Waltz was the only person who I think was perfect for the role. Thank you for your awesome review, I really enjoyed it! 😀

~Hira~
Email: Enamoredsoul(at)gmail(dot)com

By: Poncho

Poncho — Thu, 28 Apr 2011 03:27:57 +0000

I heard the same reviews from a lot of people, actually. They thought the whole thing lacked the good angst of a melodrama, and that there was zero chemistry between Pattinson and Witherspoon.

Adding to what le0pard say. I do think Waltz is getting typecasted. And that’s sad, since I think he’s genious.

Thanks for this. I think I’ll wait ’til they air this movie on TV to watch it, if I care by then.

By: Pop Culture Nerd

Pop Culture Nerd — Wed, 27 Apr 2011 21:10:52 +0000

Yes, Holbrook had much more screen presence in the few scenes he had than Pattinson did in the whole movie. I’m not a Pattinson hater (he’s Cedric Diggory!); I just think he was merely adequate and nothing special.

By: Pop Culture Nerd

Pop Culture Nerd — Wed, 27 Apr 2011 21:04:33 +0000

I liked the depiction of the circus folks, too, and their struggle to just get by. And I absolutely adored Tai; she’s the best actress in the movie!

If you love pretty gowns, your eyes will pop out at Reese’s. They’re not sparkly, but beautifully cut and made out of rich, sumptuous materials.

By: Pop Culture Nerd

Pop Culture Nerd — Wed, 27 Apr 2011 20:54:52 +0000

I didn’t see GREEN HORNET but from what you said, it sounds like Waltz might be falling into a pigeon hole. Which is unfortunate, because I think he’s brilliant and can probably play other roles besides evil men.

By: Pop Culture Nerd

Pop Culture Nerd — Wed, 27 Apr 2011 20:53:02 +0000

Which actors did you picture as the characters?