I consider myself a pretty happy person. Of course I have my grumpy days but it takes a lot for me to stop being optimistic. So I looked forward to seeing a movie called Happy-Go-Lucky (limited release Oct. 10), the latest offering from Mike Leigh (Vera Drake, Secrets and Lies). I’d heard buzz from the festivals that this movie is guaranteed to make me happy. Instead I was slightly annoyed.

The very capable Sally Hawkins stars as Poppy, a grade school teacher who embodies the titular state of being. Even when her bike is stolen, she only regrets not having had the chance to say goodbye to it. She lives with her best friend in a rented flat, goes clubbing on weekends, and takes driving lessons every Saturday from an instructor who’s always angry. Her younger sister thinks she’s being irresponsible by not buying a house and settling down to start a family but Peppy–er, Poppy–insists she’s happy and loves her life.

It’s to Hawkins’s credit that Poppy is likable but at times the script makes her do implausible and foolhardy things, all because she’s so trusting in the goodness of people. In one scene, she’s walking home alone at night in a scary part of town (already unwise) when she sees an intimidating-looking homeless man. Though the man seems unstable and ready to erupt into violence, she sits and chats with him for awhile because she doesn’t want him to be alone. It’s an incredibly altruistic act but if this movie weren’t a comedy–or if it were real life–there’d be a very good chance she wouldn’t emerge unharmed from the encounter.

Poppy’s exuberance becomes exhausting at times, with Hawkins constantly giggling, rolling her eyes, making faces, doing funny voices, acting cute. It’s as though her personality has only one note. It’d be frustrating trying to have a serious conversation with someone like Poppy because she responds to everything with a joke. I’d wonder what she’s covering up with all the funny stuff. It’s not until near the end of the movie that Poppy has some sobering moments and it’s nice to see she can actually feel a different emotion.

I certainly don’t dislike generally happy people; I much prefer them to gloom-and-doom types. I just wanted Poppy to have a more three-dimensional disposition–that’s to say, more recognizably human–and perhaps an explanation of why she’s the way she is.

Rating: Okay



  • Reply
    October 9, 2008 at 12:39 am

    Did Sally Hawkins go to the Meg Ryan school of acting?

  • Reply
    October 9, 2008 at 1:03 am

    Ha ha! She’s actually more tolerable and a better actress than Ryan. But if there were such a school, it should be shut down.

  • Reply
    October 10, 2008 at 12:31 am

    Kristin Chenoweth? Amy Adams? Do you think they all meet each other in audtions? My sister and I think that Shelley Morrison/Adrianna Barazza/Lupe Ontiveras all audition against each other…… Same thing for Craig Schaeffer/Josh Brolin/David Boreanaz………….(I KNOW I butchered the spelling of all of those names…)

  • Reply
    October 10, 2008 at 2:13 am

    I think you nailed it about Morrison, Barraza & Ontiveros all going out for the same roles!

    And speaking of Boreanaz doppelgangers, they recently cast his brother on BONES and did NOT go with Craig Sheffer! What were they thinking?! (They went with Brendan Fehr. Boo.) Boreanaz even said when he first came out to L.A. and wasn’t famous, he’d tell people he was Craig Sheffer to get into clubs and fancy restaurants.

  • Reply
    October 10, 2008 at 7:07 pm

    Hey, very cool, Eddy! Where will you be phooning?

    I think Poppy is definitely an MPDG, though I’m not sure some of the others mentioned in the article qualified. I thought Clementine had quite a bit of pain in ETERNAL SUNSHINE.

  • Reply
    October 10, 2008 at 4:03 pm

    Yesterday (10-9-08) All Things Considered on NPR did a story on Manic Pixie Dream Girls. Sounds like Poppy falls into that category.

    The dancing video made me think of Phooning. I haven’t done this myself yet. (Yes, I said “yet”.)

Leave a Reply