A Few Thoughts on THE CLOSER Series Finale & MAJOR CRIMES

*SPOILERS AHEAD: Stop reading if you haven’t watched the finale*


Going into the finale, the only things I hoped for were that Brenda wouldn’t die in the line of duty, and that she’d leave with dignity, not disgrace. I got what I wanted, but still have mixed feelings about the episode. First, the good stuff: she finally gets to take down that nasty, sleazy Phillip Stroh! Oh, man, every time he shows his smug-bastard face, I just want to punch it really hard and then do it again at least seventeen times. Billy Burke owned that character. I feel better about Brenda’s exit with Stroh behind bars, because if she couldn’t take him down, who could?

The detectives giving Brenda a replacement bag filled with Ding Dongs was sweet, and it amused me to imagine which of the men went shopping for it (my bet’s on Flynn or Sanchez). But then she said it “looks like love” and that’s when I said, “Oh, nononono. Don’t say that. We can all see it. Don’t spell it out and make it corny.” And then she said it again. (Series creator James Duff explains why in this interview: the line echoes her very first words in the pilot.)

I thought the kid, Rusty, making Brenda reevaluate her life was interesting, but after promising to look for his mother, she just foists him on Captain Raydor in the Major Crimes premiere, which is weird. Now he has to hang around so Raydor can show us a nicer, maternal side? Her taking him home, revealing that she’d raised two kids, letting him call her by her first name—it was too contrived and too much softening up all at once for me. That doesn’t make her more compelling. I actually want to see her get angry more since she’s always so steely and controlled. She lost it a little with Rusty at the station, and it was good to see her feathers can be ruffled, too. Mary McDonnell is a gifted actress and I have no doubt she’s up to the challenge of playing the division’s new leader. It’s up to the writers to make Captain Raydor as complex and vital as Brenda.

Speaking of vital, the most appealing new series regular is Kearran Giovanni as Detective Amy Sykes, the ass-kissing addition to Major Crimes. Not only is the actress fun to watch, her character has possibilities of being unpredictable. For now, she’s overly nice to Raydor, but admits to Provenza she behaves that way to further her career. How long before she decides she wants Raydor’s job and stabs her in the back?

What did you think of the finale? Will you keep watching Major Crimes?

Photo: Karen Neal/TNT



  • Reply
    August 14, 2012 at 2:33 am

    Captain Raydor will turn out to be Rusty’s biological mother; The End.

  • Reply
    August 14, 2012 at 6:19 am

    Yeah, you nailed it. I don’t know if MAJOR CRIMES will hold the same interest for my wife and I, but I’m willing to give it a chance. Thanks, Elyse.

  • Reply
    Shell Sherree
    August 14, 2012 at 5:36 pm

    I stopped watching The Closer ages ago ~ not for any particular reason, I think I just reached a point where I was juggling too many shows. But I enjoyed it ~ I expect Major Crimes will be picked up here, so I’ll definitely give it a whirl. Thanks, PCN.

  • Reply
    August 17, 2012 at 9:57 pm

    I liked Brenda’a send off (although I was bothered by the “It looks like love” end too) but can’t say that I’ll watch Major Crimes. Capt Raydor doesn’t interest me. If I happen to catch it, okay, but it won’t be on my DVR.

  • Reply
    May 26, 2013 at 7:23 am

    Hi, all:

    I followed ‘The Closer’ much more for its flawless been there, done that supporting cast led by Provensa and Flynn than Brenda or Captain Raydor.

    Though I do find Captain Raydor far less whiny than Brenda. And am willing to cut ‘Major Crimes’ a decent amount of slack.

Leave a Reply